Ad blocker interference detected!
Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers
Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.
What belongs here?Edit
Hi Fritzophrenic - I agree with your edit summary that 'I certainly wouldn't look for a PuTTY tip under "Windows"'. One reason I haven't done much with categories is that I can't get my head around them. Should any tip that works only in Windows be in Category:Windows? If so, there might be too many tips for it to be useful. If not, what is the category for?
So, I am not disagreeing with your change of the category, but I'm not really agreeing either. I'm just expressing my confusion<g>. --JohnBeckett 04:24, 30 November 2007 (UTC)
Category:Windows states that it is for "tips about using Vim with Microsoft Windows." That's pretty vague, but since it is a subcategory of Category:Integration, which is "about the integration of Vim with other programs, desktops, operating systems, etc." I view Category:Windows as a place for tips specifically about making Vim "play nice" with the Windows operating system. Tips that definitely belong in this category are tips such as:
There are other tips here that are somewhat questionable, because they are about integrating with Windows-only applications like Visual Studio, or are mostly useful in Windows but would work elsewhere, such as:
- View_Source_in_IE6_using_VIM <--IE tip, but uses the Windows registry so may be appropriate
Tips that probably don't belong at all (in my opinion) are tips like:
- 503 PuTTY numeric keypad mappings <--The tip in question
- Run_Matlab_script_under_Windows <--I'm guessing this will work anywhere MatLab is supported
- Desert_color_scheme_with_Vim_in_PuTTY <--Another PuTTY tip
- Auto_save_files_when_focus_is_lost <-- I think they thought Category:Windows was about internal Vim windows - we may want to create a category about this, actually (like Category:Tabs).
- Easy_pasting_to_Windows_applications <-- I have no way of testing this, but I highly suspect that the method discussed here will work on many other operating systems as well
Of course, these are by no means exhaustive lists. The Category:Windows category is pretty full, and probably needs some culling.
For the PuTTY tips, and for many of the xterm, SecureCRT, etc. tips, I've been thinking about creating a "Terminals" category or something alike under Category:Integration.
So, long story short, I do NOT think that Category:Windows should include every tip that only works in Windows. However, I DO think that most tips of this nature will probably be about making Vim work well in Windows and will therefore belong here. I think that tips about Windows-only applications should go either in Category:Integration or some subcategory that makes more sense, and keep Category:Windows for tips about OS integration.
Anyway, I've babbled enough - do you think we should move this to the mailing list, invite input here, or maybe put it on Category_talk:Windows?
--Fritzophrenic 16:08, 30 November 2007 (UTC)
I see what you mean. I can't bring myself to totally agree because that would imply some degree of comprehension of the issues, and I still plead confusion. A "Terminals" category does sound better than having putty tips under Windows. And yes, if you feel inclined, please move this discussion to Category_talk:Windows. If you feel adventurous, you could change the text on Category:Windows. You might need to use the extra parameter discussed on Template:CatInfo.
--JohnBeckett 23:28, 30 November 2007 (UTC)