Wikia

Vim Tips Wiki

JohnBeckett/Titles project

Talk0
1,613pages on
this wiki

< User:JohnBeckett

Revision as of 11:16, July 7, 2009 by JohnBeckett (Talk | contribs)

Introduction

After the import of tips from vim.org, many tips had unhelpful titles. While titles are not the most important part of the wiki, it is irritating to work on a tip when its title is obviously broken. Therefore, a project to rename hundreds of tips was undertaken.

Please see these pages which are generated by a script:

If you have any comments, please post them to the Vim-l mailing list. If you're not ready to join the mailing list, you could comment on my talk page.

There are many doubtful titles in titles that do not need to be changed, but I thought they were good enough at this stage. I left some fairly bad titles for tips that I think should be merged or deleted.

See the following policy for a rough set of guidelines used while devising the titles to be changed.

Policy for proposing new titles

  • Try to remove all punctuation.
  • Remove "How to" and other noise words.
  • Remove references to Vim (we assume tip is about Vim).
  • Remove "best", "good" etc (judge tip on its merits, not title).
  • Try to maintain consistent tense ("Change ..." rather than "Changing...").
  • Change 'vim' to 'Vim' (but use 'gvim' - sorry about the inconsistency).
  • Usually make all words lowercase, except proper names.
  • Use "Windows" (not "windows") if referring to Win32.
  • Try to identify the point of the tip.
  • Some titles refer to what we hope the tip will become, rather than what is currently achieved.
  • Remove some version numbers from titles (we hope to update tip so it works with current version of whatever utility the tip refers to).

Rules for page titles

See the title guidelines. Characters in a title:

Impossible:       # < > [ ] | { }
Strongly avoid:   ? _ : %
OK:               - +
Avoid:            All other punctuation

Avoid punctuation to give clean URLs (so ',' does not appear as '%2C', etc). Punctuation is ok, but where reasonable, omit it.

Originally (October 2007), we could not use "C++" in a title, so the C++ tips used the term "Cpp". Now (April 2008), the wiki software accepts "C++" and the tips have been renamed to use that term.

Obsolete redirects that I propose to delete

Each of the following is a redirect that I propose to delete (clicking one of these will go to the tip which of course will not be deleted).

Temporary names used on this wiki when "C++" was not valid in a title.


Titles that existed on this wiki from July to October 2007, before mass renaming.

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki